Mother-Nature Is Not A Wicked Witch: Oren Lyons on Oz

Share

Baum’s “Wizard” as a Utopian American Dream soft-peddles an anti-nature-prejudice amid dazzling urban-industrial landscapes. This bias at the expense of the earth’s resources contributes to today’s environmental and economic collapse.

Screenshot from the 1939 film

Dorothy’s American Dream Facing Economic and Environmental Collapse, Screenshot from “The Wizard of Oz.”

War on Nature Down the Yellow Brick Road Symbolized in L. Frank Baum’s The Wonderful Wizard of OZ

While the industrial magnates of the late nineteenth century United States peddled the “American Dream” of success through ingenuity and hard work, they pushed forward a railroad speculation bubble (sound familiar?) and a treasury run on the gold supply which collapsed the economy (hmm) known as the Panic of 1893. L. Frank Baum, sheltered son of an affluent Syracuse, NY oil baron, experienced this conundrum first hand after his family lost their wealth and he had to work for a living. Many see The Wonderful Wizard as an ostensibly populist parable with a pro-urban-industrial consumerist bias for a time of mass labor unemployment, destruction of the agricultural sector, leading to a massive movement toward the west.


Oren Lyons is a Native American Faithkeeper of the Turtle Clan of the Onondaga and Seneca Nations of the Iroquois Confederacy from Upstate New York.

Utopian “American Dream” Had the Wrong Enemy

screenshot from MGM's "The Wizard of OZ"The creation of a utopian ideal world purports to correct societal wrongs, reimagining an alternate universe of beautiful, sustainable overcoming. L. Frank Baum’s Utopian Dream of Oz can be seen as tracking a self-confidence-based way forward (aka in today’s parlance “The Secret“) out of the desolation of a drought-stricken, Mother-Nature-cursed, Wall-Street-and-Washington-caused collapsed agricultural society known as “Kansas.”

Like today, our industrial economy has largely collapsed because of Wall Street bank speculation and our environment continues to suffer the externalities of capitalism’s anti-nature bias. We need a new OZ, one that envisions Baum’s Wicked Witch (Mother Nature) as the answer. To not follow the Yellow Brick Road (gold), but learn from the numerous societies Baum illustrated in the book that thrived on cooperation and diversity, including the Flying Monkeys (the Native Americans), keeping far away from the opulent illusion of The Emerald City.

From the WW Denslow illustration in the 1900 First Edition of “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz.”

Panic of 1893 in Oz Parable

The 1894 Marches on Washington led by Ohio businessman Jacob Coxey in protest, called Coxey’s Army (Occupy Wall Street?), were observed by Baum before he gained fame. His Utopian Dream envisioned Dorothy as the typical American Dreamer, practical, sensible and resourceful, yearning for home and family. The “girl next door” joins forces in the Land of Oz with the self-doubting Scarecrow (the intellectually challenged American farmer), Tin Woodman (the heart-seeking industrial worker), and Cowardly Lion (the weak opposing Populist Party presidential candidate, William Jennings Bryan).

They march on the yellow brick road (the gold standard) to the Emerald City, the pretend-value-emerald-hued (greenbacks-money seen because of green-eyeglasses) Capitol (or Washington DC), demanding relief from the Wizard, interpreted as the President (either Cleveland or McKinley). Dorothy’s shoes (made of silver in the book, not the familiar ruby depicted in the movie) maybe symbolize the free silver movement as an alternative to the gold standard (the road of yellow brick) because the shortage of gold precipitated the Panic of 1893.

Baum’s Urban Abundance and a New Industrial Ethic

Rather than a truly populist parable, however, the book celebrates the opulence and magic of the Emerald City, and the power of positive thinking (not necessarily hard work), traits associated with the urban industrial consumer culture of the turn of the century (and still quite alive today). Baum’s Utopian Dream advocates that gold paves the road to success and fulfillment, but obstacles hide at every turn. The Wicked Witch of the West, the Wild West, untrammeled nature (drought, cyclones), stands in the way of the Dream and and must be overcome. This “utopian” world-view asserts that power and prosperity depend upon overcoming nature and its Flying Monkeys, the Indians (as Mr. Oren Lyons in the video below asserts as Baum’s maybe noble “Pets of the Government”). Many may also see the Wicked Witch of the West as the wealthy western oil and railroad barons, but his own personal history and his advocacy for finding wonder in technology and industrial operations belies that somewhat.

Time to Apologize to the Witch, Our Mother

This soft-peddled world-view of anti-nature-prejudice amid dazzling urban-industrial landscapes, manifested for another hundred years of capitalist expansion at the expense of the earth’s resources, has led us to today’s environmental and economic collapse.

Maybe we do need to choose a different enemy, to survive in this Oz-like paradise another 100 years.

Earth Island Institute’s Sacred Land Film Project produces a variety of media and educational materials — films, videos, DVDs, articles, photographs, school curricula materials and Web site content — to deepen public understanding of sacred places, indigenous cultures and environmental justice. Our mission is to use journalism, organizing and activism to rekindle reverence for land, increase respect for cultural diversity, stimulate dialogue about connections between nature and culture, and protect sacred lands and diverse spiritual practices. For the last decade we have focused on the production and distribution of the documentary film, In the Light of Reverence.We are currently developing a four-part series on sacred places around the world, entitled Standing on Sacred Ground.

Sources

Sacred Lands Film Project http://www.sacredland.org/index.php/oren-lyons-on-the-wizard-of-oz

The Yellow Brick Road to Utopia http://userwww.sfsu.edu/~gwtuma/

Oz Populism Theory http://www.halcyon.com/piglet/Populism.htm

Political Interpretations of “The Wonderful Wizard of OZ.” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_interpretations_of_The_Wonderful_Wizard_of_Oz

 

Print Friendly
Share
Jack Eidt

About Jack Eidt

Writer, urban theorist, and environmental advocate, Jack Eidt careens down human-nature's all consuming one-way highway to its inevitable conclusion - Wilder Utopia. He co-founded Wild Heritage Planners, based out of Los Angeles, California. He can be reached at jack (dot) eidt (at) wilderutopia (dot) com.